Posner, Richard A. : University of Chicago Law School
Richard A. Posner is Judge, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, and a senior lecturer at the University
of Chicago Law School.
Review
[Posner's] analysis of the political crisis surrounding disclosure of President Clinton's affair with Monica
Lewinsky is the most trenchant and illuminating yet. His precision about constitutional law and about definitions
of perjury, subornation of it and obstruction of justice gives his narrative the tension of a thriller. And his
judgments about key players--Clinton, Kenneth Starr, Congressional leaders, intellectual and academic defenders
of the president, all the lawyers involved, the Supreme Court (for letting the Paula Jones lawsuit proceed with
Clinton in office)--are scathing, unsparing, elegant and witty.
--New York Times Book Review
Posner shows that, despite its lurid and shameful origins, the [Clinton-Lewinsky] episode raised questions of law
and morality that are profoundly important to the direction of the country and to our sense of the American political
order. His analysis transforms the impeachment into an event of abiding significance. Mr. Posner works with unusual
care through each of the moral and legal questions of the impeachment process. He considers all sides and possible
interpretations of each event. But he does not hesitate to hand down strong judgements.
--George L. Priest, Wall Street Journal
In so many ways, [Posner] is a perfect man for the task [of analyzing the Clinton-Lewinsky affair], and this book
doesn't disappoint...His most valuable contribution is legal. In a way only good judges can do, he manages both
to portray the ambiguity of constitutional law--and few areas are as ambiguous as the constitutional criteria for
impeachment--and yet not shy away from judgement about what actually happened and what to make of it...Posner deftly
takes us through [the] constitutional and political mazes...[and] shows that there actually is a final answer to
the question of what perjury and obstruction of justice are, and at least some large common ground as to what might
be the constitutional grounds for impeachment.
--Andrew Sullivan, New York Times Book Review
Posner's great asset is his intellectual honesty. He pierces the gaseous clouds of Clinton's defense to make compelling
arguments that the president committed perjury and obstructed justice. He absolves Starr of obsessive prurience
and vindicates the media's reporting of the case. He ridicules the Senate's performance, as well as the chief justice's
robes. But Posner also concludes that the office of independent counsel has died a well-deserved death, that the
Supreme Court blew the Paula Jones case, and that Starr got carried away by prosecutorial excess. He skewers the
doomsayers of the moralistic Right for wringing their hands over what, to Posner, is still a vibrant republic.
--John Aloysius Farrell, Boston Globe
A bravura performance by United States Circuit Court Judge Richard A. Posner. He deftly examines the endless constitutional,
political and social angles of President William Jefferson Clinton's impeachment ordeal...[An Affair of State is
a] first-rate dissection of Mr. Clinton's impeachment drama flush with long-headed prudential wisdom and insights.
--Bruce Fein, Washington Times
We fortunately have a distinguished jurist's opinion in An Affair of State which amounts to a retrial of the president
with Posner on the bench. One could scarcely imagine a more fitting judge...[Posner] is possessed of one of the
most synoptic and probing intellects in the country, or the world. That he does not flinch from raining scorn on
the Supreme Court and even on the chief justice (to whom Posner is nominally an underling) suggests the sharpness
of mind, independence of spirit and biting wit that make his book an intellectual feast. At last, something good
has come of the Clinton-Lewinsky-Jones-Starr affair.
--Jonathan Raugh, Washington Post
An Affair of State is an impressive compilation of the facts and the opinions of one of our nations foremost jurists...[Posner's]
description, dissection and reaction to what went right, and mostly what went wrong, in the impeachment process
contrasts with the emotional hyperboles that marked much of the impeachment debate. An Affair of State is worth
the time for anyone who still has an interest in thinking and talking intelligently about this remarkable episode
in American history.
--Michael R. Lufrano, Chicago Tribune
Of [the Clinton-Lewinsky] analyses, the most insightful is An Affair of State.
--David Kusnet, Baltimore Sun
Richard Posner's An Affair of State will hardly be welcomed by President Clinton's enemies; his friends will like
it even less. Obviously, then, this book demands our attention...Precision, critical analysis, and devastating
wit are the hallmarks of [Posner's] writings.
--Stanley Kutler, Times Higher Education Supplement [UK]
Unlike the unholy mess it dissects and untangles, An Affair of State is a cool little gemstone of logic and reason,
a rational antidote to partisan excess, and a short, elegant guide for the perplexed. Among the first of what will
be many books to look back at the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, it should be the touchstone against which all others
are measured, having no evident bias except toward clarity. Richard Posner does not seem to like most of the people
described in this book, much less to share their agendas. One cannot deduce here which party he backs, whom he
voted for in recent elections, or whose positions he tends to endorse. This is the strength of his book, and its
claim to authority.
--Noemie Emery, National Review
Harvard University Press Web Site, February, 2002
Summary
New York Times Book Review Editors' Choice for Best Book of the Year, 1999
Los Angeles Times Book Prize Finalist, 2000
President Bill Clinton's year of crisis, which began when his affair with Monica Lewinsky hit the front pages in
January 1998, engendered a host of important questions of criminal and constitutional law, public and private morality,
and political and cultural conflict.
In a book written while the events of the year were unfolding, Richard Posner presents a balanced and scholarly
understanding of the crisis that also has the freshness and immediacy of journalism. Posner clarifies the issues
and eliminates misunderstandings concerning facts and the law that were relevant to the investigation by Independent
Counsel Kenneth Starr and to the impeachment proceeding itself. He explains the legal definitions of obstruction
of justice and perjury, which even many lawyers are unfamiliar with. He carefully assesses the conduct of Starr
and his prosecutors, including their contacts with the lawyers for Paula Jones and their hardball tactics with
Monica Lewinsky and her mother. He compares and contrasts the Clinton affair with Watergate, Iran-Contra, and the
impeachment of Andrew Johnson, exploring the subtle relationship between public and private morality. And he examines
the place of impeachment in the American constitutional scheme, the pros and cons of impeaching President Clinton,
and the major procedural issues raised by both the impeachment in the House and the trial in the Senate. This book,
reflecting the breadth of Posner's experience and expertise, will be the essential foundation for anyone who wants
to understand President Clinton's impeachment ordeal.
Table of Contents
Dramatis Personae
Chronology
Introduction
The President's Conduct
Prosecution and Defense
The History, Scope, and Form of Impeachment
Morality, Private and Public
Should President Clinton Have Been Impeached, and If Impeached Convicted?
The Kulturkampf
Lessons for the Future
The Balance Sheet
Acknowledgements
Index